Proposal to start sign language exams needs a reality check, say experts
October 18, 2018
In an attempt to promote inclusive education, the National Institute of Open Schooling has announced that it is strongly considering the idea of introducing sign language exams for students with hearing disabilities.
NIOS Chairman Girish Sharma has said that idea was born after a deaf student questioned the relevance of having only Hindi and English as the language medium. By introducing sign language, the NIOS wants to enable all students to be assessed in the medium they are most comfortable with.
NIOS plans to frame a bank of questions in sign language and send it to its 21 regional centres across India. The board administers secondary and senior secondary exams to out-of-school students, equivalent to CBSE and Council For The Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE).
The announcement has been welcomed on social media by many. For instance, the Vision for Health Welfare and Special Needs (VISHWAS), a Gurugram NGO working in the field of disability and inclusive development, has lauded it as a "much wanted initiative that will give opportunity and flexibility to students with speech and hearing impairments to participate in an appropriate manner".
Activist Nipun Malhotra, who recently moved a petition seeking to get sign language officially recognized, tweeted, "Fantastic that NIOS is considering sign language exams for Deaf students."
However, there are concerns that the ground reality does not support such an ambitious plan.
As Anita Iyer, Founder EKansh Trust points out, there is no uniform sign language spoken across India.
The main support system for communication is language. How will they introduce this in the whole country when days of the week, like Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, etc. are signed one way in Delhi, in another way in Pune and differently in the South? How are they going to assess the children?" - Anita Iyer, Founder, Ekansh Trust
The lack of sign language teachers apart, another concern relates to the plan of hiring sign language experts to assess the children.
"There is no vocabulary or syllabus to assess the children. Courses are not taught in sign language either, so how will assessments be done? How many teachers even know sign language? When the children are not taught in sign language in the first place, how will they be tested?," says Iyer.
The principal of a Pune school, who does not wish to be identified, admits that teachers struggle because they are not taught any ISL. While children from different places have their own signs, they have also not formally been taught ISL for want of any full-fledged courses.
Indeed, hiring interpreters for the specific purpose of assessing deaf students could backfire as this goes contrary to the standard approach, where until Class 10, students are assessed by their teachers, who are often in the best position to judge their knowledge levels and skills.
This could also increase chances of cheating and misinterpretation, says Iyer. "We are already battling bad practices among scribes for students with visual impairments. Similar situations will definitely arise with hearing impaired students using interpreters for exams."
Instead, the focus should be on addressing the faults that lie at the foundation level, says Ruma Roka, Founder, Noida Deaf Society, which educates and trains deaf youth using Indian sign language.
"If we can make education accessible to deaf people through teachers who know sign language, that is important. This way students can read and write the examination themselves. Getting an interpreter to interpret the exam questions will help if that's what it means. But giving an answer in sign language would require the assessors to also know and understand sign language, or else have an interpreter translate for them."
A first step could be the formalization of ISL. Experts say that what is being taught in government-run institutes does not suffice for Class 10 syllabus in all subjects.
Formalization and a very large dictionary will serve students, their families and educators well, according to Iyer.
"Teachers are also struggling and would welcome a comprehensive course that would prepare them to address students with hearing impairments. A formal Indian sign language would mean they can teach anywhere in India."
No doubt, the NIOS' intentions are well-founded. What is missing, however, is a an approach that takes into account the hard realities and diverse needs of students.
Watch in Sign Language
- Updated MBBS curriculum with disability competencies to come into effect from 1 August, confirms MCI
July 20, 2019
- Mumbai's Wilson College shows the path to inclusion with new faculty member Payal Bhattad
July 18, 2019
- Kerala High Court upholds guidelines for therapy centres in the state
July 17, 2019
Read more on Newz Hook
- Headlines July 19, 2019 ‘Chandrayaan 2’ mission rescheduled to 22 July
- Get-hooked July 20, 2019 Parenting Corner - Adults with Autism
- Headlines July 14, 2019 6 dead, lakhs homeless in Assam floods
- Get-hooked July 13, 2019 Trending stories on NewzHook this week!
- Education July 20, 2019 Updated MBBS curriculum with disability competencies to come into effect from 1 August, confirms MCI
- Headlines July 20, 2019 Karnataka trust vote adjourned to Monday
- Headlines July 19, 2019 One conviction in high profile murder of UK teen in Goa
- Events July 16, 2019 Living Well with Epilepsy: An Interactive Session
- Events July 16, 2019 International Autism Conference
- Get-hooked July 18, 2019 Trolled for a disability, UPSC topper Ira Singhal highlights need for inclusive education
Want to feature your inspiring story or share an event with the disabled community? Write to:
Newz Hook - Accessible News