Skip to main content
  • Accessibility
  • Headlines
  • Coronavirus-News
  • Get-Hooked
  • Technology
  • Education
  • Employment
  • Parasports
  • Ask Bhavna
  • NHBrandView
  • Independent Living
  • Lifestyle
  • NH Videos
×
Newz Hook – Changing Attitudes towards Disability Logo
  • Stories
  • Videos
  • Inclusive
  • NH Voice
  • Login
COVID-19 Notification by Government in Accessible Format

Accessibility Tools

Text Size:

Contrast Scheme:

  • C
  • C

Reset

  • Home
  • Accessibility
  • Review petition challenging 50% vision, hearing disability limit for judge’s post to be filed next week

Review petition challenging 50% vision, hearing disability limit for judge’s post to be filed next week

Exterior shot of Supreme Court
Accessibility February 15, 2019
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
0

The Supreme Court bench order stipulating a 50% disability limit in hearing and vision impairment for the post of civil judge is all set to be challenged.

Next week, Advocate V Surendra Mohan plans to file a review petition seeking that the order be placed before a larger bench.

Advocate Mohan was held ineligible for the post of civil judge by the bench of Justices Ashok Bhushan and K M Joseph as he has a 75% vision disability. The bench was hearing his appeal against the Madras High Court‘s dismissal of his writ petition challenging the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC)‘s order that only someone with a 40-50% vision and hearing disability was eligible.

Advocate Mohan, who is all set to join the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) as a Public Prosecutor soon, has made it clear that he is not interested in applying for a civil judge’s post but is fighting for a larger cause.

I challenged the Tamil Nadu government and the Commission’s decision to fix the reservation at 40-50% in the High Court because how can such a letter be binding? As per the RPWD Act 2016, any change has to be done by a proper mechanism, by setting up a committee which will conduct a research into why such an exemption is being made and after that the Disability Commissioner gets to take a call. But no such step was taken in Tamil Nadu. – Advocate V Surendra Mohan

The larger question is how the SC bench could give such an order in light of the fact that Rajasthan has a visually impaired serving civil judge in Ajmer district, Brahmananda Sharma.

“Judge Sharma is ably discharging his duties with the help of facilities being given to him like recording witness statements, an e-speak device etc., so on what basis you are giving this 40-50% reservation?”, asks Advocate Mohan. “Where is the equality? When a blind judge in Rajasthan can work, why not a judge in Tami Nadu? The laws and procedure are the same. This means the SC has no rights to give directions to the states to improve the dignity of disabled people. When you are closing the doors for your own department, then how will your order be obeyed by other departments?”

Representing Advocate Mohan will be Supreme Court lawyer Jai Dehadrai, who has successfully argued several important cases relating to accessibility at the apex court.

“I am deeply critical of the Supreme Court’s lack of reasoning in this judgement. To say a person with 50% vision loss cannot discharge his duty is one thing but when the judgment is devoid of larger reasoning, it must be reviewed by a larger bench”.

The judgement passed by the bench is truly baffling and completely at variance with the progressive stand taken in past matters, notably the directions given to make 50% of all government buildings of the national capital and state capitals fully accessible by December 2018. Given the range of technologies available, the court should be leading the way in bringing people with disabilities into the mainstream.

The sheer injustice is one that Advocate Mohan is determined to address. “I am concerned that this order will set a precedent for other states. I may not be interested in taking up the post of a judge, but I am fighting this so that no one else is suffers. If this is rejected, I will file a curative petition”.

Watch in Sign Language

0

Support us to make NewzHook Sustainable – Make a Contribution Today

We need your continued support to enable us work towards Changing Attitudes towards Disability. Help us in our attempt to share the voices of people with disabilities that enable them to participate in the society on an equal footing!

Contribute to Newz Hook

NH Videos

Healing pain through art - Dr. Anubha Mahajan, Founder Chronic Pain India

Read more on Newz Hook

  • Technology
    Top 5 accessible video conferencing platforms for people with disabilities globally
  • Education
    Evaluate Me by My Body of Work, Not my Body
  • Get-hooked
    #GlaucomaAwarenessMonth – Early detection & treatment is critical to prevent permanent vision loss
  • Accessibility,Independent Living
    Affordable and Independent Mobility for Persons with Disabilities still a distant hope in India (series 1 of 3)
  • Get-hooked,Lifestyle
    Perceptions and misconceptions about disability
  • Employment
    InReturn Strategies is redefining the way American companies talk about diversity & inclusion
  • Accessibility,Independent Living
    McDonald’s India unveils new EATQUAL packaging specially designed for customers with limited upper hand mobility

Contribue to Newz Hook. Support us to make NewzHook Sustainable – Make a Contribution Today.

Newsletter

 Subscribe to our Newsletter

Want to feature your inspiring story or share an event with the disabled community? Write to:

editor@newzhook.com

Related News

Logos of Zoom, Teams, Slack, Webex and Meet with the words Top 5 accessible video conferencing platforms

Technology

Top 5 accessible video conferencing platforms for people with disabilities globally

Jim Atwater and Scott Brouilette, Co-founders of InReturn Strategies.

Employment

InReturn Strategies is redefining the way American companies talk about diversity & inclusion

Get-hooked

Perceptions and misconceptions about disability

Accessibility

Affordable and Independent Mobility for Persons with Disabilities still a distant hope in India (series 1 of 3)

Newz Hook - Accessible News

Download App Now!

Videos

View More

Get-hooked

Action for Autism marks 25 years, goal ahead is to focus on services for adults on the spectrum

Get-hooked

"I asked for my khukri & cut off my leg"- My Take by Ian Cardozo, 1st war disabled Indian soldier to lead a battalion

Technology

Chatbot Mera Mitra aims to be the personal companion for all things to do with disability in India

Coronavirus-news

Inclusive dance video ‘Narthana’ from Aasman Foundation is winning hearts of viewers!

Newz Hook Logo

About Newz Hook

Newz Hook is a media site focusing on Changing Attitudes towards Disability globally. We highlight stories that share insights into the lives of people with disabilities, offer solutions and create collaborations. Our focus is to have Inclusion Champions from across the globe who share knowledge about disability, inclusion & accessibility.

Lets come together to change attitudes towards disability!

Newz Hook is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Follow us on:

Related Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Partner with Newz Hook
  • Embed Newz Hook Timeline
  • Affiliate disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Contribute to Newz Hook

Our Awards

Zero Project Award Winner 2018
Back To Top
© 2019 All Right Reserved. Inclusive News India Private Limited.

Ask Bhavna

All fields are mandatory unless specified as optional.