Skip to main content
  • Accessibility
  • Headlines
  • Coronavirus-News
  • Get-Hooked
  • Technology
  • Education
  • Employment
  • Parasports
  • Ask Bhavna
  • NHBrandView
  • Independent Living
  • Lifestyle
  • NH Videos
×
Newz Hook – Changing Attitudes towards Disability Logo
  • Stories
  • Videos
  • Inclusive
  • NH Voice
  • Login
COVID-19 Notification by Government in Accessible Format

Accessibility Tools

Text Size:

Contrast Scheme:

  • C
  • C

Reset

  • Home
  • Accessibility
  • Madras High Court bench slams Medical Council of India guidelines as biased against disabled medical aspirants

Madras High Court bench slams Medical Council of India guidelines as biased against disabled medical aspirants

Accessibility May 22, 2019
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
0

“Being Blind Need Not Destroy One’s Dreams.

Powerful words from the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court slamming the new guidelines of the Medical Council of India (MCI) as “unfair, discriminatory and unlawful.

The bench of women justices said this while hearing a petition filed by J Vibin, who qualified for the National Eligibility Cum Entrance Test (NEET) with an all India rank of 285 in the disability quota. Vibin is physically challenged and has a benchmark disability of visual impairment to an extent of 75%.

Vibin was allotted a seat in Government Pudukottai Medical College Hospital in the MBBS programme. He was asked to produce a Disability Certificate from one of the assessment boards as mandated by the MCI.

Vibin appeared before the medical board approved by the MCI and was certified that he had visual impairment and Congenital Anomaly-Both Eyes and that the percentage of visual disability is 90%. He was ruled as ineligible as per MCI norms.

Vibin challenged this and a single judge bench held that the denial of admission was against the provisions of the RPWD Act. This was challenged by in the High Court , which upheld the previous order and said
that rejecting Vibin on the basis of percentage of disability violated the principles in the Constitution.

The competency of a Doctor with disability cannot be assumed, as unless it is experienced one may not understand the same. If a person with visual impairment is already a Doctor, it shall be possible for a blind person to be a Doctor. – Madras High Court order

Larger discrimination

This was not all. The court went on to make several other observations that were heartening. It noted that hospitals in India are not disabled-friendly and that it was painful to see that no time allowance is given to persons with disabilities while taking the tough medical entrance exam. It also said that candidates with learning disabilities or any other disability should not be barred from entering the field of medicine.

Dr Satendra Sigh, founder of the group Doctors with Disabilities, a group that has been campaigning against the discriminatory MCI guidelines, said the court’s observations were truly positive.

“It is heartening to see the Honourable Court including the demand of the Doctors with Disabilities movement in the judgement that we should be involved in policy decisions. I am also grateful that they have quoted from my paper published in the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics last year as to MCI Guidelines being unfair, illegal and discriminatory. This is the success of our movement that along with the Delhi Rights of Persons with Disabilities Rules 2018, Courts too are using the words ‘Doctors with Disabilities’. This is the true inclusion which we were looking for in line with nothing about us, without us.

ALSO READ:
Calcutta High Court rules in favour of medical student with mental disorder who was denied admission

Watch in Sign Language

0

Support us to make NewzHook Sustainable – Make a Contribution Today

We need your continued support to enable us work towards Changing Attitudes towards Disability. Help us in our attempt to share the voices of people with disabilities that enable them to participate in the society on an equal footing!

Contribute to Newz Hook

NH Videos

Healing pain through art - Dr. Anubha Mahajan, Founder Chronic Pain India

Read more on Newz Hook

  • Get-hooked
    Padma Awards for 2021 turn spotlight on achievers in the disability space in India
  • Coronavirus-news,Technology
    Helpline support for special needs families during COVID
  • Accessibility,Independent Living
    McDonald’s India unveils new EATQUAL packaging specially designed for customers with limited upper hand mobility
  • Get-hooked
    Amanda Gorman, first U.S. National Youth Poet Laureate, does not see her disability as a weakness
  • Get-hooked
    Kanthari helps marginalised people, including those with disabilities, drive change in their communities
  • Get-hooked
    #GlaucomaAwarenessMonth – Do’s & Don’ts of Treatment
  • Accessibility
    No Data on Violence Against Disabled Women
  • Accessibility
    Build Back “Better”: a misnomer for transportation without Accessibility and inclusivity?

Contribue to Newz Hook. Support us to make NewzHook Sustainable – Make a Contribution Today.

Newsletter

 Subscribe to our Newsletter

Want to feature your inspiring story or share an event with the disabled community? Write to:

editor@newzhook.com

Related News

Cover of Candleep Mysteries book with the title

Accessibility

Latest Dungeons & Dragons book to feature its first wheelchair accessible dungeon

kanthari founders Paul Kronenberg and Sabriye Tenberken

Get-hooked

Kanthari helps marginalised people, including those with disabilities, drive change in their communities

Accessibility

McDonald’s India unveils new EATQUAL packaging specially designed for customers with limited upper hand mobility

Images of Balan Pootheri, Venkatesh and Dr Niru Kumar

Get-hooked

Padma Awards for 2021 turn spotlight on achievers in the disability space in India

Newz Hook - Accessible News

Download App Now!

Videos

View More

Technology

#TechThursdays - EMx turns the spotlight on early intervention & inclusive education in the 3rd edition

Get-hooked

11-year-old Tanishq’s culinary skills are a treat to watch on his YouTube channel ‘Wonderfud’

Get-hooked

“If you don’t step forward to break barriers, no one else will”- My Take by Sweta Mantrii

Get-hooked

Understanding EFT - Emotional Freedom Technique

Newz Hook Logo

About Newz Hook

Newz Hook is a media site focusing on Changing Attitudes towards Disability globally. We highlight stories that share insights into the lives of people with disabilities, offer solutions and create collaborations. Our focus is to have Inclusion Champions from across the globe who share knowledge about disability, inclusion & accessibility.

Lets come together to change attitudes towards disability!

Newz Hook is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Follow us on:

Related Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Partner with Newz Hook
  • Embed Newz Hook Timeline
  • Affiliate disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Contribute to Newz Hook

Our Awards

Zero Project Award Winner 2018
Back To Top
© 2019 All Right Reserved. Inclusive News India Private Limited.

Ask Bhavna

All fields are mandatory unless specified as optional.